Second issue; cover by Ed Emshwiller |
A battered copy of the first issue; cover by Emsh |
- Keyhole Mystery Magazine [v1 #1, April 1960] ed. Dan Roberts (35¢, 130pp, digest, cover by Ed Emsh)
- 4 · The Great Elvis Presley Mystery · Will Folke & Dick Ashbaugh · ss
- 17 · Full Circle · Miriam Allen deFord · ss
- 28 · Mr. Lupescu · Anthony Boucher · ss Weird Tales Sep 1945; Author’s Choice.
- 33 · Cinderella and the Mob · Cornell Woolrich · nv Argosy Jun 22 1940
- 59 · Swan Song · Ken Murray · ss
- 66 · The Mugger · Harold Straubing · ss
- 68 · Mother Knows Best · Avram Davidson · ss
- 80 · The North Star Caper · Norman Katkov · ss
- 93 · Peeping Tom’s Scrapbook · Charles Boeckman · ss
- 98 · Murder on El Capitan · Hayden Howard · ss
- 114 · The Dog That Wouldn’t Talk · Lawrence G. Blochman · ss 1941; For Love or Money, Mystery Writers of America, Garden City, NY: Doubleday 1957
Details supplied by Tom Lesser.
Rather good choices in reprints, mixed with some solid, if not groundbreaking, original fiction, and a bit of attempted pop-culture hipness in invoking Elvis in the cover story--coauthored by Robert Bloch as "Will Folke"...
- Keyhole Mystery Magazine [v1 #2, June 1960] ed. Dan Roberts (Winston Publications, Inc., 35¢, 130pp, digest) (see Emshwiller cover above)
- ifc. · Dear Mystery Fans · [The Editor] · ed
- 4 · Letters to the Editor · [The Readers] · lc
- 6 · The Trap · Norman Daniels · ss
- 16 · Night Ride · Theodore Sturgeon · ss
- 28 · The Concealed Path [Uncle Abner] · Melville Davisson Post · ss Uncle Abner: Master of Mysteries, D. Appleton 1918
- 39 · The Diamonds [Uncle Abner] · Frank Atterholt · ss
- 45 · A Case of Homicide · Rog Phillips · ss
- 55 · The Deadliest Game · Joseph Whitehill · ss 1955
- 68 · Wife Killer · Rod Reed · ss
- 70 · Author’s Choice · Cornell Woolrich · is
- 71 · I.O.U. · Cornell Woolrich · ss Double Detective Nov 1938, as “I.O.U.—One Life”
- 84 · A Matter of Life · Robert Bloch · ss
- 90 · Born for Murder · John Collier · ss
- 105 · Rest in Peace · Avram Davidson · ss
- 110 · A Christian Burial · Mary Thayer Muller · ss
- 115 · A Kiss for Belinda [Dr. Daniel Webster Coffee] · Lawrence G. Blochman · nv Collier’s Feb 17 1951, as “Kiss of Kandahar”; given as by Laurence G. Blochman.
Details supplied by Douglas Greene.
If anything, an even better issue...at least in adding Bloch, Sturgeon and Collier originals along with another Davidson in the mix.
- Keyhole Mystery Magazine [v1 #3, August 1960] (35¢, digest)
- The Hit-Run Homicide [Fabian] · Bill Boltin · ss
- Murder in Africa · Roald Dahl · ss
- Ambition · Charles Boeckman · ss
- Fat Chance · Robert Bloch · ss
- Case of the Clumsy Cadaver · Will Folke · ss
- That Night · George Kauffman · ss
- Long Teeth · R. A. Lafferty · ss
- The Careful Murderer · Miriam Allen deFord · ss
- Straight and Narrow · John Collier · ss
- Triangle · William T. Harrel · ss
- Broker’s Special · Stanley Ellin · ss Ellery Queen’s Mystery Magazine Jan 1956
- The Zarapore Beat [Terrence O’Reilly] · Lawrence G. Blochman · nv Argosy Oct 24 1936, as “O’Reilly Sahib”
And with the third and final Winston issue, deFord's back, and she and Bloch and Collier are joined by Roald Dahl, the busy Charles Boeckman, and then-new writer R. A. Lafferty--one has to wonder how new a George Kauffman item could be. A four year old Ellin reprint from EQMM seems a bit recent, but EQMM would do similar things...and it was Ellin (today is the anniversary of his death, oddly enough). Note also, still pinning hopes to a pop-music crossover appeal, with Fabian Forte, of all people, as a detective.
Meanwhile, and for no obvious reason edited anonymously (with radio/comics-style "editorial hosts" who are a Beast and a spider), Shock showed some signs of being aimed a bit younger, while still offering a lot of first-rate work...albeit even more of it reprinted and not a little of that set chestnuts from the horror and suspense literature. EC Comics legend Jack Davis did all three covers, much in the style of their horror comics or Mad...while some of the fiction was a bit grim even for the more receptive kids:
- Shock—The Magazine of Terrifying Tales [v1 #1, May 1960] (Winston Publications, Inc., 35¢, 132pp, digest)
- 4 · Feast Day · Matthew Lynge · ss
- 14 · Bianca’s Hands · Theodore Sturgeon · ss Argosy (UK) May 1947
- 23 · The Band Played On · Gene Dilmore · ss
- 28 · Graveyard Rats · Henry Kuttner · ss Weird Tales Mar 1936
- 35 · The Crowd · Ray Bradbury · ss Weird Tales May 1943
- 44 · Parlor Game · Reginald Rose · ss
- 51 · The Monkey’s Paw · W. W. Jacobs · ss Harper’s Monthly Magazine Sep 1902
- 61 · Forever After · Jim Thompson · ss
- 68 · The Empty Man · Anthony Boucher · ss F&SF Apr 1952, as “The Anomaly of the Empty Man”
- 83 · Crickets · Richard Matheson · ss
- 89 · Specialty of the House · Stanley Ellin · nv Ellery Queen’s Mystery Magazine May 1948
- 106 · Green Thoughts · John Collier · ss Harper’s Magazine May 1931
- 122 · The Tenant · Avram Davidson · ss
But, then again, there are worse things for young minds to be warped by than "Bianca's Hands"...the Davidson story was reprinted in F&SF a decade later, and a decade+ after that in Dennis Etchison's anthology Masters of Darkness III. Originals by Richard Matheson, Jim Thompson, Reginald Rose (12 Angry Men), and Davidson are nothing to dismiss out of hand, even if the Davidson is probably the closest to major work by its author. A young Lenny Kaye, a decade+ before starting to play with Patti Smith Group and putting together the Nuggets anthology albums of garage-rock and protopunk, wrote a published fan letter about this issue.
- Shock—The Magazine of Terrifying Tales [v1 #2, July 1960] (Winston Publications Inc., 35¢, 130pp+, digest)
- ifc. · Dear Reader: Here’s Wishing You a Shudderful Time · [The Editor] · ed
- 4 · Letters to the Editor · [The Readers] · lc
- 7 · Bright Segment · Theodore Sturgeon · nv Caviar, Ballantine 1955
- 30 · Mean Mr. Murray · Avram Davidson · ss
- 37 · The House Party · Stanley Ellin · ss Ellery Queen’s Mystery Magazine May 1954
- 54 · Pin-Up Girl · Will Folke · ss
- 62 · 9-Finger Jack · Anthony Boucher · ss Esquire May 1951
- 68 · The Emissary · Ray Bradbury · ss Dark Carnival, Arkham House: Sauk City, WI 1947
- 75 · Baby Picture · Mort Golding · ss
- 79 · Laughing Moths · Miriam Allen deFord · ss
- 87 · Sredni Vashtar · Saki · ss The Westminster Gazette May 28 1910
- 92 · The Frog Prince · John Collier · ss Presenting Moonshine, New York: Viking 1941
- 99 · Our Feathered Friends · Philip MacDonald · ss When Churchyards Yawn, ed. Cynthia Asquith, London: Hutchinson 1931
- 109 · The Doll · Pat Gibbons · ss
- 114 · Yours Truly—Jack the Ripper · Robert Bloch · ss Weird Tales Jul 1943
Details supplied by Darren Heil.
Originals by Davidson again, deFord, and Bloch again as "Will Folke"...one does get the sense that Dan Roberts, whoever he? was, definitely edited both Winston titles.
- Shock—The Magazine of Terrifying Tales [v1 #3, September 1960] (35¢, 132pp, digest)
- 6 · Final Performance · Robert Bloch · ss
- 18 · The Witch · Ralph E. Hayes · ss
- 25 · Open House · Charles Beaumont · ss The Hunger and Other Stories, Putnam 1957
- 35 · The Man Who Knew Everything · Edward D. Hoch · ss
- 41 · Skeleton · Ray Bradbury · vi Rob Wagner’s Script Apr 28 1945
- 57 · Cold Case · Ed Ritter · ss
- 62 · Skin · Roald Dahl · ss The New Yorker May 17 1952
- 78 · Chanceyville · John Anthony West · ss
- 85 · Johnson Looked Back · Thomas Burke · ss Night-Pieces, London: Constable 1935
- 90 · Beautiful Dreamer · R. A. Lafferty · ss
- 97 · A Bottomless Grave · Ambrose Bierce · ss San Francisco Examiner Feb 26 1888
- 104 · Moon-Face · Jack London · ss The Argonaut Jul 21 1902
- 110 · The Kennel · Maurice Level · ss Hearst’s Magazine Aug 1920; translated from the French (“Le Chenil”, Le Journal, 1906).
- 116 · Prison Ball · John Rublowsky · ss
- 124 · Cat Killers · Donald E. Westlake · ss
And the third and last Winston issue features originals by Edward Hoch, Lafferty, Westlake, and journeyman John Anthony West, among others...including one of the best stories of Bloch's career, "Final Performance," a story that is in more ways than one a hardboiled punch in the gut.
It's a real pity that these magazines didn't do better in the suddenly crowded, then thinned out, marketplace of 1960...and even more a pity that Winston apparently sold the title rights and unpublished inventory, if any, to Pontiac Publishing, already responsible for some of the bottom of the barrel sleaze titles, of which their 1961/62 continuations of Keyhole and particularly Shock were prime examples. Don't confuse the originals with these decomposing revenants...
And see the indices at Phil Stephenson-Payne's The Crime, Mystery, & Gangster Fiction Magazine Index, the source of the indices above and several of the cover images. For a sense of how these magazines went, try Peter Enfantino's reviews of the archetypal Web Detective.
For more of today's titles, please see Evan Lewis's blog (filling in this week for Patti Abbott, on assignment in Traverse City).
And given that I've posted about Shock (this one rather than the several other magazines of that title, not even counting its shudder-magazine continuation) and Fear! and the Magazine of Horror and its stablemates, (and the various revivals of Weird Tales starting after the turn of the next decade), I suppose doing a take on the Other horror magazines of note in the 1960s, such as Macabre, The Arkham Collector, Bizarre! Mystery, and even the all-reprint Strange Fantasy might well follow...along with such early '70s colleagues as Coven 13/Witchcraft and Sorcery, The Haunt of Horror (the fiction magazine from Marvel, before they turned it into a large-format comic), Weirdbook and others...
And given that I've posted about Shock (this one rather than the several other magazines of that title, not even counting its shudder-magazine continuation) and Fear! and the Magazine of Horror and its stablemates, (and the various revivals of Weird Tales starting after the turn of the next decade), I suppose doing a take on the Other horror magazines of note in the 1960s, such as Macabre, The Arkham Collector, Bizarre! Mystery, and even the all-reprint Strange Fantasy might well follow...along with such early '70s colleagues as Coven 13/Witchcraft and Sorcery, The Haunt of Horror (the fiction magazine from Marvel, before they turned it into a large-format comic), Weirdbook and others...