Monday, January 13, 2025

Polar Frost (among other Polar sodas) v. Sparkling Ice v. Cascade Ice v. Petey's Bing Beverages (refreshingly without ice nor rime) among other low/no sugar lines

I'm a Type 2 diabetic (it runs in both lines of the family...I'm the lucky one thus in my nuclear fam), and I definitely love a good soda (to a fault). Hence, low/no-sugar soda beverages will tend to get my attention when I can find them.  Below are samples photos from various lines (though the Cascade photo is closest to a complete-line representation), with a few comments on how they strike me. I will drink perhaps too much of all of them.

Polar has very impressive lines of seltzers, and flavors I enjoy in liter and  2L bottles such as Diet Orange Dry (an orange-juice flavored soda) and a similarly good diet half-and-half mixture, though their good cream soda and other "standard" soda flavors are oddly hard to find around the Philadelphia area of late. Their "Frost" line of juice-flavored beverages has one of the best sets of flavors (vying with Bing), with a possible disadvantage for some of having caffeine in the mix. Favorite flavors among the Frosts: Lemonade and Arctic Twist.


Sparkling Ice might just be the oldest of these lines...at least, it was the first I encountered, with a delightful low-sugar lemonade/tea canned beverage I've not seen in years, about thirty years in fact. Back when we might be more afraid of the possible link between Alzheimer's and aluminum cans than the effects of microplastic body-pollution and plastic bottles. Sparkling, like Cascade, doesn't add caffeine to their "Ice" line. Favorite Sparkling flavors: Lemonade and Fruit Punch (among those still extant I've been able to try).























Cascade has perhaps the heaviest syrup to seltzer presence of these lines in my experience, which works for some flavors better than others; they also give the consumer a few milliliters more per bottle than their slim-bottle competitors (not quite a swallow's-worth of difference, but interesting and not advertised in any way). This photo array includes a number of flavors I've not yet seen in my local markets...though given that I can find these in Acme supermarkets, these days part of the same conglomerate that owns Safeway and a number of the major California "legacy" chains, they might have some availability in the widest array of grocers nearby any readers this post gets, at least in the US. Favorite flavor I've had the opportunity to try: Cranberry Pomegranate. I'll seek out McIntosh Apple sometime soon.

While the Bings are the smallest line, they might just have the highest "batting average" for me, in terms of how much I like all the flavors I've tried...but I'm a sucker for the oddly (to me) very short-lived set of apple soda flavors over the decades we've seen, and their apple-juice flavored entry is perhaps the best that isn't simply (more expensive) carbonated cider. Mildly caffeinated, like the Polar Frost line. Favorite flavor: Crisp (Apple/Cherry with apple the stronger flavor).

And other flavors that I will overindulge in include Dr. Brown's and other diet cream sodas (surprisingly few carried by local markets of late), the Polar-affiliated Gosling's Diet Ginger Beer and Vernor's Diet Ginger Soda...but nearly everyone who makes a diet ginger beer does a decent job of it, but usually, unlike Gosling's and Vernor's, at an elevated price. And diet birch beers...seems almost as if these are a northeastern US thing exclusively, a more or less wintergreen-flavored soda, with some small differences between New England clear "white" birch beers and mid-Atlantic "red" birch beers...as with McIntosh apples, something I missed in my five years in Hawaii (and I've been missing apple bananas and peanuts taro, and body surfing, since moving back east--even if I started body surfing on family trips to Virginia Beach in my childhood). While in the DC area, guarana soda seemed more widespread than a bit farther north...though it took till moving to the Philadelphia suburbs to find the slightly expensive Cheerwine...which reminds me of Dr. Pepper with the cola flavor absent.

I don't approve of "seasonal flavors"--I want a good flavor year-round, thanks--but Polar particularly likes to experiment thus, and their best winter flavor this year is Spiced Pear Cider...the Wegman's Supermarket chain, which alas dumped its store-brand soda flavors this past year (a good, economical diet grapefruit soda among them...though they retained their stock of Polar's diet "half-and-half" mixer, rather similar and as good), has their (not quite as good but even less expensive) Cranberry Apple seltzer back out this winter.

Any soft drinks that you might enjoy, even if not as borderline-addicted to as I am to some of these? I am interested in what flavors I might be missing...







Almost-black red birch beer and clear white birch beer.

2 comments:

neer said...

They all seem tempting, Todd.

Todd Mason said...

They all can be, Neeru!